Welcome to Ted's Montana Grill
Ted's Montana Grill is a culinary homage to the timeless flavors of the American West, embodying a spirit of hospitality and indulgence. Set in Columbus, Ohio, this charming establishment specializes in bison dishes alongside classic steakhouse fare, promising a unique dining experience. Signature offerings like the “Flying-D” bison chili and premium steaks are crafted with care, evoking nostalgia for the rustic charm of old Montana. Guests rave about generous portions and vibrant flavors, from delectable burgers to satisfying desserts. The inviting atmosphere, enhanced by warm service, makes Ted's a go-to destination for hearty family meals and memorable gatherings.
- 4169 Worth Ave, Columbus, OH 43219, United States Hotline: +1 614-337-1457
Welcome to Ted's Montana Grill, a culinary gem tucked away at 4169 Worth Ave, Columbus, OH. This restaurant brings a uniquely rustic yet modern atmosphere, transporting diners back to the frontier days of Montana. The cozy ambiance, combined with a menu that champions the rich flavors of both beef and bison, creates an inviting destination for families and food lovers alike.
Ted's is not just a meal; it’s an experience defined by its commitment to high-quality ingredients and exceptional flavor. Renowned for its hearty steaks and bison dishes, the grill has received rave reviews from satisfied patrons eager to indulge in generous portions of perfectly cooked meats. The reviews tell a story of pleasure and satisfaction, with many declaring it their top choice for steak in town.
- Starters: The menu kicks off with a selection of enticing starters, such as the Bison Nachos and Salt & Pepper Onion Rings—both praised for their remarkable flavor and generous servings.
- Salads: The side salads, like the Chili and Wedge Salad, offer a refreshing contrast, perfectly complimenting the richly flavored entrées.
- Entrees: Signature dishes include the bold, flavorful Bison Burger and the Grilled Caesar, which can be customized with either cedar plank salmon or grilled chicken. Each entrée is celebrated for its quality, with customers frequently noting how each bite is packed with flavor.
- Desserts: Finish off your meal with heavenly desserts, like the Strawberry Shortcake or satisfying Chocolate Chip Cookies, both of which leave diners with sweet memories long after the meal is over.
The heartfelt testimonials speak volumes, with many guests commenting on the relaxing atmosphere and impeccable service. One customer raved about the Buffalo steak, describing it as "unparalleled in flavor and tenderness," encapsulating the essence of Ted's commitment to offering the best of the best. Others laud the ample portion sizes, which ensure that you leave not just satisfied, but thoroughly content.
In every sense, Ted's Montana Grill is a testament to the ideals of home-cooked quality, served in a warm and welcoming setting. Whether a casual family dinner or a romantic night out, this grill perfectly marries great food with a delightful atmosphere. If you’re seeking a memorable dining experience rich with authentic flavors and heartfelt service, Ted's Montana Grill is undoubtedly worth the visit.

Very good food and relaxing atmosphere. It feels like a place from days past, better than most of the other 'high-end' steak houses in town! This was our second time here; we will be back again. Update: We have been to several 'top end' steak houses. This is still the best steak in town. I don't know who their steak cutter, cook, or chef is, or who is, but the Buffalo steak is unparalleled in flavor or tenderness. It takes me back to the small towns of 'Old' Montana and Colorado before they become so trendy, over 30 years ago, when they were ignored by but 'pop' culture!!!! I will absolutely bring friends and family here! Even better than the new Cameron Mitchell places !!!!!! Capitol Grill doesn't even come close ( dry and basically flavorless, waste of time and money!).

Always good food. I like the atmosphere. The apple crisp dessert was fabulous

We were hesitant to go because we thought it would be expensive. However, we were pleasantly surprised by how reasonable the prices were. I got the Avalon Burger which was juicy despite being slightly over medium-done. Honestly it was one of the best burgers I've ever had. The fries that came with it we're better than average. My wife got salmon which she enjoyed with some creamy and flavorful mashed potatoes. The kids add a grilled cheese and fries and a chicken tenders and fries which we're gone at the end of the meal, a sign that they approved.

Ted's Montana Grill is a fantastic spot for a family meal. Every visit there has been a delight, with generous portions and flavorful dishes that never disappoint. The steaks are a standout, consistently cooked to perfection and packed with flavor. The desserts are equally impressive, with portions large enough to share. On my most recent visit, my wife and I enjoyed a great meal. She ordered a steak cooked medium well, and it came out cooked to perfection exactly as she requested, and it was enormous and delicious. I opted for a grilled chicken sandwich, it was possibly the best I've ever had. The seasoning was remarkable, adding an extra layer of flavor that really complimented the sandwich. For dessert, my wife chose the strawberry shortcake. It was massive and delicious, perfect for sharing. I had the chocolate chip cookies, which were large and more than satisfying. Overall, Ted's Montana Grill is a top choice for family dinners. The quality of the food, the generous portions, and the welcoming atmosphere keep us coming back. If you're looking for a place with hearty meals and tasty desserts, this place is definitely worth a visit.

My husband and I finally made it here! This was a spur of the moment decision and I was hesitant that they might be busy or the restaurant would be loud. Thankfully, neither was the case. There was no wait and the music was at a pleasant volume. Surprisingly, there were only a handful of people dining in so I'd assume it's much busier here during dinner time. Our waiter (wish I could remember his name, he said he's also the bartender) was polite and prompt. For our starter, we tried the chips and dip. The chip were a little bit on the salty side but good nonetheless. My husband really enjoyed the dip! For entrées, I ordered the Bison Brisket and my husband ordered Red Rock Chicken Sandwich. My meal was . I love a good, hearty meal! My husband's critique for his meal was that he wished the bun had been toasted and his fries were a bit soggy. We ended the meal with a dessert (and by we, I mean me ). I had the chocolate chip cookie with two scoops of vanilla bean ice cream. Overall, great first visit! My critique is that we stood at the front host stand for seemingly too long until someone approached us. We had begun to think that you had to check in online to reserve a table since we saw a handful of workers before anyone came over.

My husband and I went to the Nationwide Arena District and did not have a pleasant experience at all. The Proprietor, Mr. Longo reached out to us. He apologized and offered a gift certificate to come back and try them again either at Nationwide or Easton location. My husband decided to give the Easton location a try. We walked into the location and immediately it felt cleaner and more up to the standard of price point. We were greeted after a short wait at entrance and seated. The manager, I am assuming, came and took our drink order while our waitress was finishing up a table. First thing…clean glasses. The wine glass was sparkling clean. McKenna, our waitress was absolutely fabulous. Stark difference in atmosphere, cleanliness and taste of the food. We ordered the Salt and Pepper Onion rings again and the Crab cake. They were not burnt, you could see the seasoning and for some reason they were in a basket, not a plate and there were a lot more of them then before. The Crab cake comes with a kale salad that was bitter and tasteless before…but flavorful and delicious here. My husband again got steak, and so did I. Side salad for me (which was the same size as the “entree salad” at the Nationwide location, and asparagus, cooked medium. Everything was PERFECT. Husband’s steak med rare, perfect. Garlic mashed potatoes still didn’t have any garlic flavor but were good with the gravy. Green beans were amazing. We even ordered dessert, which we did not do before. We got their Seasonal Strawberry Shortcake which was phenomenal. Once again..thank you Mr. Longo for the invitation back. We enjoyed the Easton location immensely. Since we live closer to the Nationwide Arena area, here’s hoping the same things can be accomplished there.

First time here with a friend. She explained to me before going that not only did they offer Bison, but also a Beef option. The atmosphere is nice and cozy, and could be considered somewhat romantic due to the dim lighting. I was surprised and delighted by the pickled cucumbers served instead of bread before the meal. I thought the cucumbers were a different yet nice choice. The server was polite and appropriate. The food was bought out in a timely manner despite how busy they were. I'd recommend this establishment and I would return.

I have to say, very nice establishment. The waiters were nice and the food came out way faster than I expected. We had just finished the Bison Nachos(very good by the way), and our food was out. The Bison short ribs taste like we cooked them at home...delicious! The drink I had was nice as well. Great restaurant indeed! I highly recommend this place.