Ted's Montana Grill Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Ted's Montana Grill, a dining experience that captures the essence of the American West. Located in Columbus, Ohio, this restaurant tantalizes the palate with its commitment to quality ingredients, featuring an impressive menu showcasing both bison and beef options. Starting with the decadent St. Phillip's Island Crab Cake and the flavorful Bar None Bison Sliders, guests are treated to both rich flavors and generous portions.

The entrée salads, such as the Balsamic Blue Steak Salad, perfectly balance fresh greens with premium steak, while classic dishes like the Avalon Burger and Grilled Caesar highlight the grill's expertise. Desserts, notably the strawberry shortcake and chocolate chip cookies, promise a sweet ending to your meal. Ted's Montana Grill stands out, not just for its hearty meals but for the inviting atmosphere that recalls a bygone era—making each visit a delightful escape.

Starters

Bar None Beef Sliders

Four beef sliders, topped with American cheese and served on a warm yeast roll with a side of homemade chips.

$16.25

Bar None Bison Sliders

Four bison sliders, topped with American cheese and served on a warm yeast roll with a side of homemade chips.

$18.50

Bison Nachos

Pepper jack, bison chili, fresh toppings.

$18.00

Salt & Pepper Onion Rings

Hand-breaded, horseradish sauce.

$14.50

Homemade Chips

Fresh-cut chips served with scratch-made ranch onion dip.

$11.50

Karen's "Flying-D" Bison Chili

Hearty flavors of slow-cooked bison, tangy tomatoes, ranch-style beans and original spices, topped with cheddar cheese, red onion and freshly sliced jalapeños.

Grilled Shrimp

Ciabatta toast, arugula, lemon vinaigrette

$18.50

St. Phillip's Island Crab Cake

Jumbo lump crab, guacamole, kale salad.

$20.75

Chili And House Salad

Karen's "Flying-D" bison chili with a house side salad.

$20.75

House Salad

Iceberg, romaine, organic spring mix, cucumber, vine-ripened tomato, croutons and red onion with your choice of housemade dressing.

$9.25

Caesar Salad

Romaine, Parmesan, croutons, “eggless” Caesar dressing.

$9.25

Wedge

Bacon, vine-ripened tomato.

$11.50

Chili And Caesar Salad

Karen's "Flying-D" bison chili with a Caesar side salad.

$19.75

Chili And Wedge Salad

"Flying-D" bison chili with a wedge side salad.

$23.00

Side Salads

Entrée Salads

Chicken Chopped Salad

Iceberg, grilled chicken, roasted corn, garbanzo beans, vine-ripened tomato, green pepper, red onion, fresh chopped basil, cucumber, bacon, tossed in fresh basil vinaigrette dressing.

Balsamic Blue Steak Salad

Premium steak, iceberg, romaine, organic spring mix, cucumber, blue cheese, bacon, vine-ripened tomato, balsamic reduction, topped with onion straws.

Big Sky Grilled Salad

Iceberg, romaine, organic spring mix, bacon, cheddar, egg, vine-ripened tomato, avocado and housemade croutons with your choice of grilled chicken, beef burger, bison burger or cedar plank salmon.

Grilled Caesar

Romaine, Parmesan, croutons, “eggless” Caesar dressing with your choice of cedar plank salmon or chicken.

Smashburger

Two 3oz. patties, American, diced red onions, sweet and spicy pickles, Ted’s ranch sauce on a buttered brioche bun

Delicious Duo

Two 3oz burgers (bison and beef), American cheese, lettuce, tomato, dill pickle, mustard remoulade on a sesame bun, served with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

$18.00

Cheeseburger

Bison or beef burger topped with your choice of American, cheddar, pepper jack or Swiss cheese with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

Ted's Bacon Cheeseburger

Bison or beef burger topped with Cheddar or Swiss, smoky bacon and grilled onions with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

Naked Burger

Perfectly simple bison or beef burger with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

Avalon Burger

Bison or beef burger with Gruyère and blue cheese, bacon-caramelized onions, roasted garlic aioli and baby arugula with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

Blue Creek Burger

Bison or beef burger topped with Blue cheese and smoky bacon with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

Swiss & Mushroom Burger

Bison or beef burger topped with Swiss cheese, mushrooms and sour cream with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

Skinny Dip Burger

Bison or beef burger served bunless with avocado, vine-ripened tomatoes and kale salad.

George's Cadillac Burger

Bison or beef burger topped with BBQ sauce, cheddar, bacon, served with a side of mustard and fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

Green And Hot Burger

Bison or beef burger topped with pepper jack, grilled jalapeñoes, guacamole and Sriracha aioli with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

Red Rock Burger

Bison or beef burger topped with pepper jack, jalapeñoes, cilantro, onion straws and Z-sauce served on ciabatta bread with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

Veggie Burger

(Vegan) Lettuce, tomato, roasted garlic aioli, cracked wheat bun

$19.00

1977 Americas Cup

American, bacon, grilled onion, mushroom, fried egg. beef or bison. items are served raw, or undercooked, or may contain raw or undercooked ingredients. consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Canyon Creek

Cheddar, bacon, jalapeño, raspberry jam, fried egg. beef or bison.

Burgers

Poultry

Brick Chicken Plate

All-natural chicken breast, expertly seasoned and cooked on our cast iron grill to perfection. Served with garlic mashed potatoes and parmesan roasted broccoli.

$23.00

Red Rock Chicken Sandwich

All-natural grilled chicken breast, pepper jack cheese, jalapeñoes, cilantro, fried onion straws and Z-sauce served on ciabatta bread with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

$18.50

Snowcrest Chicken Grilled

Grilled all-natural chicken breast, mustard remoulade, lettuce, vine-ripened tomato, dill pickle chips on a cracked wheat bun with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

$18.50

Snowcrest Chicken Fried

Fried all-natural chicken breast, mustard remoulade, lettuce, vine-ripened tomato, dill pickle chips on a cracked wheat bun with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

$18.50

Chicken Skinny Dip Sandwich

Bunless, avocado, with vine-ripened tomatoes and your choice of side.

$18.00

Chicken Green & Hot Sandwich

Chicken breast topped with pepper jack, grilled jalapeñoes, guacamole and Sriracha aioli with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

$18.50

Absolute Best Fish Sandwich

Lightly breaded cod, lettuce with chive caper tartar sauce on a cracked wheat bun, served with kale salad and fresh-cut fries.

$19.00

7 Oz Salmon

Fresh salmon seasoned with salt and pepper and roasted on a cedar plank, served with garlic mashed potatoes, Parmesan roasted broccoli and a side of horseradish sauce.

$28.75

9 Oz Salmon

Fresh salmon seasoned with salt and pepper and roasted on a cedar plank, served with garlic mashed potatoes, Parmesan roasted broccoli and a side of horseradish sauce.

$32.25

St. Phillip's Crab Cakes

Southwestern seasoned crab cakes, served with a side of guacamole, Parmesan roasted broccoli and kale salad.

$41.50

Seafood

Bison

Bison Brisket

Pulled bison brisket, gravy, served with garlic mashed potatoes and buttered carrots.

$31.25

Bison Meatloaf

Bison meatloaf with gravy served with garlic mashed potatoes and buttered carrots.

$26.50

Bison Short Ribs

Slow-braised bison ribs, served with garlic mashed potatoes and buttered carrots.

$31.25

Meatloaf Sandwich

Bison meatloaf sandwich topped with pepper jack, grilled onions on ciabatta bread, served with fresh-cut fries.

$19.75

Beef Filet (8 Oz)

Aged, hand-cut in our on-premise butcher shop, seasoned and finished with lemon butter, choice of two sides.

$47.25

Bison Filet (8 Oz)

Aged, hand-cut in our on-premise butcher shop, seasoned and finished with lemon butter, choice of two sides.

$51.75

Beef Delmonico Ribeye (14 Oz)

Aged, hand-cut in our on-premise butcher shop, seasoned and finished with lemon butter, choice of two sides.

$46.00

Bison Delmonico Ribeye (14 Oz)

Aged, hand-cut in our on-premise butcher shop, seasoned and finished with lemon butter, choice of two sides.

$51.75

Beef New York Strip (12 Oz)

(12oz) Certified Angus Beef New York Strip aged, hand-cut in our on-premise butcher shop, seasoned and finished with lemon butter, choice of two sides.

$37.00

Bison New York Strip (12 Oz)

(11oz) Bison New York Strip aged, hand-cut in our on-premise butcher shop, seasoned and finished with lemon butter, choice of two sides.

$42.75

Steaks

Sides

Fresh Cut French Fries

Our proprietary, gluten-free fries.

$8.25

Salt & Pepper Onion Rings

Hand-breaded, horseradish sauce.

$8.25

50/50 Fries & Onion Rings

Half fresh-cut fries, half hand-breaded onion rings.

$8.25

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Garlic mashed potatoes with gravy.

$8.25

Buttered Carrots

Buttered carrots.

$8.25

Parmesan Roasted Broccoli

Parmesan roasted broccoli.

$8.25

Baked Potato (AFTER 4PM ONLY)

$7.50

Kid’s Beef Steak

Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.

$12.00

Kid’s Bison Steak

Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.

$14.50

Kid's Mac N' Cheese

Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.

$8.75

Kid’s Salmon

Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.

$12.75

Kid's Beef Cheeseburger

Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.

$10.00

Kid's Bison Cheeseburger

Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.

$12.25

Kid's Grilled Cheese

Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.

$8.75

Kid's Chicken Tenders

Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.

$11.00

Kid's Grilled Chicken

Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.

$11.00

Kids

Sips

Coca-Cola Classic

The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.

$4.75

Diet Coke

A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.

$4.75

Sprite

The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.

$4.75

Boylan’s Root Beer

$5.25

Bottled Spring Water

$5.25

Bottled Sparkling Water

$5.25

Ted's Wildberry Cheesecake

Cheesecake topped with wildberries and finished with a buttery graham cracker crust, topped with hand-whipped cream.

$10.50

Strawberry Shortcake

Fresh-baked sweet drop biscuits, topped with vanilla ice cream, housemade whipped cream and fresh strawberries

$15.00

Brownie

Caramel sauce, coffee icing, vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, kahlua fudge sauce.

$9.50

Vanilla Ice Cream

$7.00

Desserts